Before a Sherd Becomes a Story: Reading Ceramic Assemblages

A practical research note on ceramic counting, classification, and context, drawing on Lasisi and Robin Garcia’s study of the Ìjẹ̀bú palace assemblage.

A pottery fragment can invite an immediate story: a meal, a household, a journey, a ceremony. Archaeological practice earns that story through a series of smaller decisions. What was recovered together? Which fragments belong to the same vessel? How were forms distinguished, and what exactly was counted? Before a ceramic assemblage can support an interpretation of social life, the record must make these decisions available for scrutiny.

Olanrewaju Lasisi and Robin Garcia’s 2025 study, Ceramics of Power and Identity: The Ìjẹ̀bú Palace Assemblage in the Context of Yoruba Regional Networks, offers a useful starting point. Published in Lakhomi Journal: Scientific Journal of Culture 6(2): 141–154, it examines palace ceramics in relation to wider Yorùbá traditions and locally distinctive combinations of features. The authors connect vessel forms and decoration to questions of consumption, interaction, and identity. This note considers the recording choices that make such questions investigable.

The first practical distinction is between fragments and vessels. The Chartered Institute for Archaeologists’ pottery recording guidance distinguishes sherd count, weight, and estimates of vessel numbers. These measures answer different questions. Imagine a teaching exercise in which one bowl breaks into twenty pieces and another into four. Counting fragments alone would give the first bowl five times the numerical presence, although the exercise began with two vessels. Any percentage needs a clearly stated denominator.

Classification deserves the same attention. A recording form should explain what qualifies a fragment as a rim, a base, or a body sherd, and how a proposed vessel form was identified. The CIfA guidance also calls for a glossary explaining recording codes. Such definitions allow another researcher to understand a category before comparing it with a different collection. In African ceramic research, that comparability should be developed alongside regional knowledge and locally meaningful distinctions.

Context then determines which comparisons are worth making. A palace collection and a domestic collection may address different activities; a deposit may also require investigation of how its contents accumulated. A Standard for Pottery Studies in Archaeology, introduced by Historic England, treats pottery as evidence for consumption and site formation as well as chronology. Its project-wide approach encourages planning the analysis before the final report. The general lesson travels usefully, while the questions and classifications must fit the assemblage being studied.

Community knowledge can sharpen those questions. A proposed documentation project might invite potters and other knowledgeable participants to discuss vessel names, techniques, and distinctions that an initial catalogue overlooks. Their contributions should retain attribution, language, and the circumstances of the conversation. Researchers could then examine how those accounts relate to the excavated material. This creates room for informed interpretation without assuming that a contemporary explanation automatically establishes the use of every older vessel.

For a practical teaching exercise, students could describe the same small group of fragments independently, compare their classifications, and explain each disagreement. They could calculate more than one measure of abundance and discuss how their conclusions change. Lasisi’s publicly shared Introduction to Archaeology teaching document provides a wider context for learning how material remains become archaeological arguments. The exercise proposed here would make the connection between observation and interpretation tangible.

At Nirvana Archaeology, this is a productive principle for discussing material culture: let a reader follow the reasoning from the recorded fragment to the proposed social relationship. Lasisi and Garcia’s palace study shows why the eventual questions matter. Careful recording gives future researchers and community collaborators the means to revisit those questions, refine the categories, and develop interpretations that the first catalogue could not yet contain.

Olanrewaju Blessing Lasisi — original concept; AI-assisted development/presentation.

+

Leave a Reply